HARROW · 13+ ACADEMIC SCHOLARSHIP 2025
2025 · 哲学与应用伦理2025 · Philosophy and Applied Ethics
…
本讲内容What this lesson covers
这份 75 分钟的 Philosophy and Applied Ethics 试卷,先给 30 分钟阅读一份真实议会法案的前六页,内容是帮助晚期病人结束自己生命。题目只有一道,陈述里包含两个主张:一个道德原则,以及这部法案是否足够完善。课程教孩子逐条读法案、正反两面论证、给出有理有据的结论;最常见的失分点是只谈原则、忘了第二个主张。
This 75-minute Philosophy and Applied Ethics paper gives thirty minutes to read the first six pages of a real parliamentary Bill on helping terminally ill adults to end their own lives. The single question has two claims in one statement, a moral principle and a judgement that this Bill is adequate, and the lesson teaches how to read the Bill section by section, argue both sides and reach a justified verdict. The common trap is to write only about the principle and forget the second claim.
- 先读题:两个主张和四个要点The question first: two claims and four bullet points
- 法案是什么,以及如何用好 30 分钟阅读时间What a Bill is, and how to use the thirty minutes of reading time
- 第 1 至 3 条:谁可以申请、绝症与行为能力Sections 1 to 3: who can ask, terminal illness and capacity
- 第 4 至 9 条:谈话、声明、两位医生及其职责Sections 4 to 9: conversations, declarations, two doctors and their duties
- 第 9 条:must 与 may 一个小词背后的大问题Section 9: how one small word (must or may) carries a large argument
- 拆解陈述:两个主张,以及 adequate 等关键词Unpacking the statement: two claims, and words like adequate
- 支持的论点:自主权、同情与层层保障Arguments for: autonomy, compassion and layers of safeguards
- 不同的看法:生命神圣、无形压力、姑息治疗与条文漏洞A different view: sanctity of life, quiet pressure, palliative care and gaps in the text
- 法案之后的变化,作为证据中立使用Updates since the Bill, used neutrally as evidence
- 写作计划、七段范文与常见错误清单Planning, a seven-paragraph model essay and a checklist of mistakes