HARROW · 13+ ACADEMIC SCHOLARSHIP 2021
2021 · 哲学与应用伦理2021 · Philosophy and Applied Ethics
…
本讲内容What this lesson covers
这份 75 分钟的卷子给出五篇短文献和一个待评价的观点:“人类没有自由意志”,并印有决定论和自由意志的定义。课程讲解如何发现定义里暗含的一步推理、每篇材料究竟是谁的观点、如何把材料组合成论证,以及在得出结论前如何权衡正反两方。
This 75-minute paper gives five short sources and one statement, "Humans don't have free will", to evaluate, with printed definitions of determinism and free will. The lesson teaches how to spot a hidden step in a printed definition, who is really speaking in each source, how to pair sources into an argument, and how to weigh the case for and against before reaching a verdict.
- 题目观点、印出的定义与四个提示问题The statement, the printed definitions and the four key questions
- 三种立场:强决定论、自由意志论、相容论Three positions: hard determinism, libertarianism, compatibilism
- 材料 A · 亚里士多德论自愿与非自愿行为Source A · Aristotle on voluntary and involuntary action
- 材料 B · 斯宾诺莎:感觉自由不等于真正自由Source B · Spinoza: feeling free is not being free
- 材料 C · 拉普拉斯的“全知智者”Source C · Laplace's intelligence that knows everything
- 材料 E · 霍金谈偶然性与改变看法Source E · Hawking on chance and a change of mind
- 材料 D · 艾耶尔的两难,及其并非他本人的结论Source D · Ayer's dilemma, and why it is not his own conclusion
- 惩罚问题、正反论证,以及附另一种结论的范文Punishment, plus the case for and against, and a model essay with a second verdict